PEER REVIEW METHOD for the Catcher in the Rye paper

Step 1:  Read the paper carefully for information and understanding

Step 2:  Identify aspects of the Toulmin method

You will need colored pencils or highlighters for this assignment.  Identify the following elements in your partner’s paper.  Designate a different color for each element.

•  Context for the subject:               [this can be bracketed]
• The claim statement
• Each sub claim
• Each data point / piece of evidence
• Each warrant
• The counter claim
• The rebuttal

Part 3:  Annotate your partner’s paper

After you code the paper, annotate each of the above aspects—what positive feedback can you give each section?  What suggestions do you have to make the paper stronger?